I need opinions.

Is “Casting Moonshadows” worth reading?

I’ve heard good things, but I’ve also heard bad. And I mean, it’s really freaking long.

Thoughts?

1. sarahsupastar answered: Casting Moonshadows is SPECTACULAR.Bloody Brilliant characterization & development,but depressing as Hell.Read it! But only if you like angst
2. townofclay answered: I really liked it, but if it bothers you that it isn’t finished yet, maybe you should wait until it is. But it’a great read :)
3. save-calvin answered: I didn’t really like it.
4. zorasrevolve answered: Eh, I suppose. If you ever have nothing better to do. It wasn’t reeeaaally good, but it’s worth a look. :)
5. whisperingtoghosts answered: I started reading it but stopped. Mainly because it went against a lot of fanon and the characterisation made me sad xD
6. mirrorneuron answered: I stopped reading it after some point because of the drama and bad characterization. It’s really not worth it, you’ll just waste your time.
7. bookish-but-corruptible answered: nope. remi and siri. in this story remus is a straw man, not a character, and he’s certainly not remus.
8. starry-anise answered: YES. For the love of all that is Wolfstar, read it. It is an absolutely amazing fic, though it’s incomplete ;u;
9. moony-remus-lupin answered: It’s not the best. And plus there’s a lot of ‘Remi’ and ‘Siri’ sooooo yeah. Hahaa.
10. theycallmesir answered: It seems to be important to the fandom… But I found it over dramatic with some of the worst characterization I’ve ever seen.
11. damascened answered: No, it’s not worth the read. Remi and Siri. I think that is reason enough.
12. gelastic posted this